Best Fireplace Inserts Consumer Reports

Choosing the best fireplace inserts consumer reportsmay be challenging as you have to screen through the large amount of similar products available on the market. Don’t worry though; we have got our hands on 10 trendy and top rated products and below is our recommendation.

In Hurry? Checkout Our Top Pick Of Best Fireplace Inserts Consumer Reports.

Our Top Pick
Pleasant Hearth 20

9.7/10 our score

Best Fireplace Inserts Consumer Reports

Rank Product Name Score
1
Pleasant Hearth 20

Pleasant Hearth 20″ Electric Crackling Natural Wood Log
9. 7
2
MEECO'S RED DEVIL 1105 Fireplace Insert Insulation

MEECO’S RED DEVIL 1105 Fireplace Insert Insulation
9. 5
3
Duraflame DFI021ARU-05 Electric Log Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed, Antique Bronze

Duraflame DFI021ARU-05 Electric Log Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed, Antique Bronze
9. 1
4
Duraflame Electric DFI030ARU Infrared Quartz Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed and Logs, Black

Duraflame Electric DFI030ARU Infrared Quartz Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed and Logs, Black
8. 8
5
Midwest Hearth Fireplace Insert Insulation 10' Roll w/Self Adhesive Backing

Midwest Hearth Fireplace Insert Insulation 10′ Roll w/Self Adhesive Backing
8. 6
6
Homedex 50

Homedex 50″ Recessed Mounted Electric Fireplace Insert with Touch Screen Control Panel, Remote Control, 750/1500W, Log/Crystal Options
8. 2
7
XtremepowerUS 60

XtremepowerUS 60″ Large Recessed Electric Fireplace Wall Mounted Electric Insert Heater Fireplace Color Flame Remote Control, 1500W
8. 0
8
JAMFLY Electric Fireplace Insert 18

JAMFLY Electric Fireplace Insert 18″ Freestanding Heater with 7 Log Hearth Flame Settings and Remote Control,1500w,Black
7 .7
9
Sunday Living Electric Log Set Heater, Insert Fireplace Heater with Realistic Flame and Ember Bed, 21 Inch, Adjustable Brightness, 8-Hour Timer, Remote Control, Antique Black Frame, IFP606B

Sunday Living Electric Log Set Heater, Insert Fireplace Heater with Realistic Flame and Ember Bed, 21 Inch, Adjustable Brightness, 8-Hour Timer, Remote Control, Antique Black Frame, IFP606B
7. 4
10
BELLEZE 23

BELLEZE 23″ 1400w 3DInfrared Embedded Fireplace Electric Insert Heater Indoor Glass View, Adjustable Log Flame w/Remote Control, Black
7. 2

1. Pleasant Hearth 20″ Electric Crackling Natural Wood Log

Pleasant Hearth 20

9.7/10 our score

  • Real wood American Birch logs , Wattage – 1350 watts
  • Realistic randomly glowing ember bed
  • Quick and easy installation – plugs into any 120 volt outlet
  • Realistic crackling sound
  • Insert into any fireplace
  • Replaces existing wood grate, burner, or log set

2. MEECO’S RED DEVIL 1105 Fireplace Insert Insulation

MEECO'S RED DEVIL 1105 Fireplace Insert Insulation

9.5/10 our score

  • 10′ x 1-1/2″ wide strip of fiberglass insulation
  • Use between a fireplace insert and the surrounding masonry
  • Forms a smoke and gas tight seal
  • Replace every time a woodstove insert is removed for cleaning
  • Made in the USA

3. Duraflame DFI021ARU-05 Electric Log Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed, Antique Bronze

Duraflame DFI021ARU-05 Electric Log Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed, Antique Bronze

9.1/10 our score

  • 4,600 BTU heater provides supplemental zone heating for up to 400 square feet
  • Rolling, pulsating, realistic log set and ember bed projects flames onto the back of an existing fireplace
  • Flame effect can be operated with or without heat, providing the ambiance of a gentle rolling fire all year long
  • Portable unit comes fully assembled and ready to heat and requires no venting or gas lines. Includes an owner’s manual and easy-to-follow instructions.
  • Safe for kids and pets – stays cool to the touch

4. Duraflame Electric DFI030ARU Infrared Quartz Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed and Logs, Black

Duraflame Electric DFI030ARU Infrared Quartz Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed and Logs, Black

8.8/10 our score

  • 5,200 BTU heater provides supplemental zone heating for up to 1,000 square feet to help you save money
  • The infrared quartz heat helps to maintain the natural humidity in the air, resulting in comfortable heat without drying out the room’s air
  • Instantly switch your existing fireplace to electric when you set this logset on the floor of your fireplace
  • Rolling, pulsating, realistic log set and ember bed projects flames onto the back of an existing fireplace
  • Flame effect can be operated with or without heat, providing the ambiance of a gentle rolling fire all year long

5. Midwest Hearth Fireplace Insert Insulation 10′ Roll w/Self Adhesive Backing

Midwest Hearth Fireplace Insert Insulation 10' Roll w/Self Adhesive Backing

8.6/10 our score

  • SELF ADHESIVE BACKING – Pressure sensitive adhesive. Simply peel off backing and apply.
  • 10 FOOT LONG ROLL – 10′ long by 1-1/2 inch width.
  • LIMITS AIR LEAKS – Sealing the gap between insert and masonry helps to limit air leaks.
  • 225 DEGREE RATED – Fiberglass insulation is rated to 225 degrees farenheit.
  • MAINTAIN YOUR FIREPLACE – Replace your old insulation every time the insert is removed for cleaning.

6. Homedex 50″ Recessed Mounted Electric Fireplace Insert with Touch Screen Control Panel, Remote Control, 750/1500W, Log/Crystal Options

Homedex 50

8.2/10 our score

  • ☀Modern Home Decor: The fireplace brings relaxation and comfort into the home, ideal for family room, bedroom, hotel lobby or anywhere supplemental heat and ambiance is needed. Touch screen buttons together with remote control enable convenient user experience, no matter using it in winter for warm heating or other seasons for decorating.
  • ☀Efficient Two Heat Settings: Upper front heater blower (vent at the top). Two heat settings (high 1500W and low 750W) can heat up to 400 square feet room quite nicely. The thermostat can control the room temperature from 60℉ to 97℉ to suit user’s preference. The countdown timer can be set to turn off the fireplace up to 12 hours.
  • ☀Realistic Flame Effect: Ultra High Intensity LED lights provide very bright and realistic flame effect. Two options for ember bed: Log set or crystal stones to meet your need. 9 different flame color settings cater to your desired ambience. The flame effect can be operated with or without heat for year-round ambience. 5 color intensities to control brightness from bright to dim.
  • ☀Safe and Energy Saving: Use LED technology instead of gas or oil, save time and energy as this fireplace produces no messy or harmful things, safe for people and pets. And the Homedex fireplace is CSA certificated and equipped with safety cut-off device for overheat protection. The heat maintains the natural humidity in the air, which will not make the room too dry.
  • ☀In-wall/Wall-hung Installation: This electric fireplace is specially created for in-wall recessed mounting. Second choice: wall-hung mounted. Just plug in 110V outlet and enjoy. Please contact our customer service team if you have questions about installation, damage or missing parts.

7. XtremepowerUS 60″ Large Recessed Electric Fireplace Wall Mounted Electric Insert Heater Fireplace Color Flame Remote Control, 1500W

XtremepowerUS 60

8/10 our score

  • All Year Around Ambiance – Perfect for the cold seasons, features two heat settings: high and low. Heat vents are located on the upper front area. The heat level can be adjusted according to the user’s preference, making this fireplace a functional and practical fixture. The fireplace can be turned all the way up in freezing weather to keep you snug and toasty. For slightly chilly weather, it can be set on low to provide ample warmth without being too hot
  • Dual Installation Wall/Insert – In Wall Recessed Design specially designed for fully or partially recessed in wall, also can be wall mounted and freestanding. The black and larger linear glass design offer a sleek and modern look.
  • Realistic Flame Effects To create the cozy atmosphere of a traditional fireplace, this electronic unit emits authentic-looking flames that emulate a real fire. It has three color changing options, along with multiple settings, from a soft ember glow or an intense blaze. Heat and flame settings can be operated through a remote control
  • Front air outlet design can be perfectly installed under the TV more than 8″-inch distance. Whisper quiet blower heating, 750-watt and 1500-watt heating modes,12.5 amps plug-in 110v outlet, heating for 400 sq.ft
  • Safety and Comfort – ETL, UL, CSA Certificate Approved. It also has auto-heat kill safety to avoid the super heating. The infrared heat is good for maintaining the natural humidity within the air without making the room too dry

8. JAMFLY Electric Fireplace Insert 18″ Freestanding Heater with 7 Log Hearth Flame Settings and Remote Control,1500w,Black

JAMFLY Electric Fireplace Insert 18

7.7/10 our score

  • Realistic Flame Effects: Life-like resin logs and a glowing ember bed with realistic flame technology,7 flame brightness’s adjustment.
  • Two Heating Mode:2 Heating Setting Energy Saving and Safe, 750w &1500w front air heating system can radiate soft warm air airflow, can heating up to 400 square feet room.
  • Environmental Protection and Energy Conservation: No gas, ethanol, propane, or gel cans required. No special vents, chimneys, or power sources needed, 100% energy saving LED technology.
  • Dimensions:19.66″ L X 9.85″ W X18.54″ H.5100BTUS,12.5AMPS,plug-in 120v .Convenient remote control included,dual control panel and remote control.
  • Customer Service: Free replacement for installation problems, damage and missing parts within 1 year. Replace & refund within 1 month.

9. Sunday Living Electric Log Set Heater, Insert Fireplace Heater with Realistic Flame and Ember Bed, 21 Inch, Adjustable Brightness, 8-Hour Timer, Remote Control, Antique Black Frame, IFP606B

Sunday Living Electric Log Set Heater, Insert Fireplace Heater with Realistic Flame and Ember Bed, 21 Inch, Adjustable Brightness, 8-Hour Timer, Remote Control, Antique Black Frame, IFP606B

7.4/10 our score

  • REALISTIC 3D FLAME EFFECT: The LED log set of this electric fireplace heater comes with realistic red burning logs and dancing flame light effects, creates a warm and cozy home atmosphere. The flame effect can be operated with or without heat, just enjoy the ambience of a rolling fire all year long.
  • ADJUSTABLE FLAME SETTINGS: The brightness of flame will constantly cycle from high to low, and there are five flame brightness settings to makes this insert fireplace heater suitable for your needs.
  • 8-HOUR TIMER & REMOTE CONTROL: This electric log insert is equipped with 8-hour timer (1H, 2H, 4H, 8H) adds you more convenience and set your suitable time up and the fireplace heater will turn off automatically when the time’s up. Infrared remote control provided for easy operation while you are away from the heater at cold night.
  • DECORATIVE FOR MERRY CHRISTMAS: 5000 BTU and 1500W power electric log set heater provides supplemental zone heating for your living room, bedroom or basement, creates a warm atmosphere to the whole family. Equipped with overheat function, it will shut off automatically to offering intimate protection for you.
  • ENERGY SAVING & PORTABLE DESIGN: This ETL standard heater works with electricity and requires no venting or gas lines, no need to worry about chimney fires, and messy ashes of a real wood stove. 21″(L) x 8.7″(W) x 12. 2″(H) perfect for anywhere in the room that could use some warmth and charm.

10. BELLEZE 23″ 1400w 3DInfrared Embedded Fireplace Electric Insert Heater Indoor Glass View, Adjustable Log Flame w/Remote Control, Black

BELLEZE 23

7.2/10 our score

  • MAGNIFICENT DISPLAY – A beautiful and crisp LED display features a series animation consisting of glowing log and ember bed that creates realistic flames. The magnificent sight can be appreciated with or without the warm breeze from the heater
  • OPTIMAL ZONING – The 4760 BTU heater provides effective heating up to 400 square feet, optimal for warming up the entire room. The heat can be regulated using the remote control and/or the button provided in the insert
  • COMFORTABLE HEAT – The infrared quartz heat emitted by BELLEZE’s electric fireplace heater helps in creating a comfortable environment by maintaining the natural humidity of the air resulting in a moist and appropriate heat without drying out the room’s air
  • FITS PERFECTLY – Being the perfect measurement of 23 inches, this fireplace insert fits into almost every television stands, fireplace wall, bookshelf, and entertainment center. You can choose to put it on top of a table or down on the ground and it’ll still work its magic
  • EASE OF USE – Three pre-set temperature settings between 62°F and 82°F along with easy to navigate buttons on both the fireplace insert and the wireless remote control that lets you set a heating timer, control display, regulate heat, and turn the fireplace insert on or off.